Gilmore Girls Reading Challenge: “The Polysyllabic Spree” by Nick Hornby

I’ve been trying, unsuccessfully, to figure out which Gilmore Girls episode features The Polysyllabic Spree, Nick Hornby’s delightful collection of book pieces.

Music by The Polyphonic Spree is featured in “Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller” (season 5, episode 1), but I have yet to find a reference to Hornby’s book. Was its inclusion on the list an error, or does the book appear without a verbal reference? I dunno, but if you do, you are cordially invited to enlighten me!

In the meantime … whatever. The Polysyllabic Spree is on the list, and I embrace any opportunity to (re)read Nick Hornby.

I’ve read all but one of his novels and love them all, deeply, for both their fully realized characters and their ethos. They portray the world as hard and unrelenting but where it’s nevertheless possible to find hope, meaning, and redemption. I believe this to be true in the real world as well, so visiting the imaginative ones Hornby conjures comforts me. It’s like hanging out with like-minded people who know just how to cheer me up, make me think, and make me laugh. Who doesn’t enjoy that from time to time?

The Polysyllabic Spree is a collection of his essays about books and reading, originally published in Believer magazine. (Isn’t that a grand name for a magazine?!) Each chapter is one of his pieces. Each piece begins with two lists: one of the books he bought that month and one of those he read. Sometimes these lists correspond; oftentimes they don't. (Ohhh boy, can I relate to that.) He reads broadly, with passion, curiosity, and respect. He’s thoughtful, insightful, thoughtful, and fabulously witty.

Besides the intellectual stimulation and pleasure of reading an articulate, intelligent book lover's insights, I laughed out loud often reading this book. (And I do so love to laugh.) His humor can be very self-deprecating. This happens to be my favorite kind of humor since it is, I believe, a form of humility (currently the world’s most underrated virtue). 

Anyway, reading this book the first time expanded my to-be-read list by more titles than I care to confess, to be honest with you. This time around, I was enchanted by his piece on David Copperfield. (Somehow, I don’t expect you’re surprised to hear this.) I’ve read this piece over and over because it’s brilliantly observed and hilariously written. It also gets the novel, which is to say, I agree with Hornby’s assessment (I’m sure he’ll be relieved to hear this).

His final thoughts on the book mirrored my experience of it precisely, and I signed with sympathetic identification reading these words:

“For the first time since I’ve been writing this column, the completion of a book has left me feeling bereft: I miss them all. Let’s face it: usually you’re just happy to hell to have chalked another one up on the board, but this last month I’ve been living in this hyperreal world, full of memorable, brilliantly eccentric people, and laughs II hope you know how funny Dickens is), and proper bendy stories you want to follow.”

Just so. 

We would love for you to join us on this challenge. To see the complete list of books, please visit The Gilmore Girls Reading Challenge. If you would like to participate, please email   This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .


Follow Books, Ink HamletHub